How do We Know Fat's a Problem?
by
Eleanor Mayfield
In
1908, scientists first observed that rabbits fed a diet of meat, whole
milk, and eggs developed fatty deposits on the walls of their arteries
that constricted the flow of blood.
Narrowing of the arteries by these fatty deposits
is called atherosclerosis. It is a slowly progressing disease that
can begin early in life but not show symptoms for many years. In 1913,
scientists identified the substance responsible for the fatty deposits
in the rabbits' arteries as cholesterol.
In 1916, Cornelius de Langen, a Dutch physician
working in Java, Indonesia, noticed that native Indonesians had much
lower rates of heart disease than Dutch colonists living on the island.
He reported this finding to a medical journal, speculating that the
Indonesians' healthy hearts were linked with their low levels of blood
cholesterol.
De Langen also noticed that both blood cholesterol
levels and rates of heart disease soared among Indonesians who abandoned
their native diet of mostly plant foods and ate a typical Dutch diet
containing a lot of meat and dairy products. This was the first recorded
suggestion that diet, cholesterol levels, and heart disease were related
in humans. But de Langen's observations lay unnoticed in an obscure
medical journal for more than 40 years.
After World War II, medical researchers in
Scandinavia noticed that deaths from heart disease had declined dramatically
during the war, when food was rationed and meat, dairy products, and
eggs were scarce. At about the same time, other researchers found
that people who suffered heart attacks had higher levels of blood
cholesterol than people who did not have heart attacks.
Since then, a large body of scientific evidence
has been gathered linking high blood cholesterol and a diet high in
animal fats with an elevated risk of heart attack. In countries where
the average person's blood cholesterol level is less than 180 mg/dl,
very few people develop atherosclerosis or have heart attacks. In
many countries where a lot of people have blood cholesterol levels
above 220 mg/dl, such as the United States, heart disease is the leading
cause of death.
High rates of heart disease are commonly found
in countries where the diet is heavy with meat and dairy products
containing a lot of saturated fats. However, high-fat diets and high
rates of heart disease don't inevitably go hand-in-hand.
Learning from Other Cultures
People living on the Greek island of Crete
have very low rates of heart disease even though their diet is high
in fat. Most of their dietary fat comes from olive oil, a monounsaturated
fat that tends to lower levels of "bad" LDL-cholesterol and maintain
levels of "good" HDL-cholesterol.
The Inuit, or Eskimo, people of Alaska and
Greenland also are relatively free of heart disease despite a high-fat,
high-cholesterol diet. The staple food in their diet is fish rich
in omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids.
Some research has shown that omega-3 fatty
acids, found in fish such as salmon and mackerel as well as in soybean
and canola oil, lower both LDL-cholesterol and triglyceride levels
in the blood. Some nutrition experts recommend eating fish once or
twice a week to reduce heart disease risk. However, dietary supplements
containing concentrated fish oil are not recommended because there
is insufficient evidence that they are beneficial and little is known
about their long-term effects.
Omega-6 polyunsaturated fatty acids have also
been found in some studies to reduce both LDL- and HDL-cholesterol
levels in the blood. Linoleic acid, an essential nutrient (one that
the body cannot make for itself) and a component of corn, soybean
and safflower oil, is an omega-6 fatty acid.
At one time, many nutrition experts recommended
increasing consumption of monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats
because of their cholesterol-lowering effects. Now, however, the advice
is simply to reduce dietary intake of all types of fat. (Infants and
young children, however, should not restrict dietary fat.)
The available information on fats may be voluminous
and is sometimes confusing. But sorting through the information becomes
easier once you know the terms and some of the history.
The "bottom line" is actually quite simple,
according to John E. Vanderveen, Ph.D., director of the Office of
Plant and Dairy Foods and Beverages in FDA's Center for Food Safety
and Applied Nutrition. "What we should be doing is removing as much
of the saturated fat from our diet as we can. We need to select foods
that are lower in total fat and especially in saturated fat." In a
nutshell, that means eating fewer foods of animal origin, such as
meat and whole-milk dairy products, and more plant foods such as vegetables
and grains.
Eleanor Mayfield is a writer in Silver
Spring, Md.
Food and Drug Administration
Publication No. (FDA) 99-2286
|